Nonqualified deferred compensation
The most criminally misunderstood tool in executive comp.
A deferred compensation election is an irrevocable, multi-year tax decision that looks like simple checkbox on an HR form. We model it against your income, your other plans and the state you'll retire in before you sign, and make huge mistakes we commonly see.
For households with $3M+ in investable assets. Serving executives nationwide.

The enrollment window
Nov–Dec
Most plans want next year's elections before this year ends. Once January starts, the decision is locked.
Why it matters
Old, misunderstood, and remembered for the meltdowns.
Deferred comp plans are a lot like a nuclear power plant. Most people only hear about the meltdowns. Run well, they're one of the most powerful tax tools an executive has.
Every deferral is a bet on two tax rates: the one you pay today and the one you'll pay in the year the money comes out. In most cases, the person making the bet knows neither number. The plan administrator can't give tax advice. Your CPA is focused on filing last year. So the decision slips through.
Listen · The Long Game with Thomas Kopelman
Super (un)sexy tax savings: Eric on 409A, 457(b) and 457(f)
Do you own a nuclear power plant that cuts your taxes, or one that melts down later? Eric walks through how to tell, and why the decision has to run through your whole plan.
70%
of eligible executives now participate, a record high.
Plan Sponsor Council of America, 2025
89%
of plans pay out at separation, a trigger you don't control. Nearly half pay at a change in control.
Plan Sponsor Council of America
$18,750
Defer $75K at a 37% bracket and take it back at 12%. That's the tax difference alone, before a dollar of tax-free compounded growth before withdrawal.
Hypothetical
The three plans
409A, 457(b), 457(f). Alphabet soup with very different rules.
The names sound alike. The tax treatment, the payout rules and the risks don't. We skip the governmental 457(b)—the most common; it avoids most of the problems below.
Corporate
409A NQDC
Who has it: Corporate executives.
You elect each year, before the year you earn the pay.
The plan sets your payout options: a lump sum or installments.
The plan also sets the triggers: separation, a fixed date, change in control, death or disability.
Watch for
One escape hatch. A re-deferral has to be elected 12+ months before the payment date and push it out at least five more years.
Hospitals · Universities · Nonprofits
Non-governmental 457(b)
Who has it: Executives at hospitals, universities and other nonprofits.
It looks like the government version. It isn't. It can never be rolled to an IRA.
The money stays an asset of your employer, exposed to its creditors.
No Roth option and no age-50 catch-up. A special 3-year catch-up can reach $49,000 in 2026.
Watch for
At separation, you may get as little as 60 days to make an irrevocable payout choice.
Senior nonprofit leadership
457(f)
Who has it: Deans, head coaches, high earning physians and college C-suites.
Taxed when it vests, not when it pays.
You pick a vesting year 3 to 10 years out, and it can never change.
Leave for a for-profit before it vests and you forfeit it.
Watch for
Timing. A $300K benefit vesting on top of peak salary can cost about $104K in federal tax. Spread across three lower-income years, closer to $35K. Hypothetical example.
Common mistakes
The five mistakes we see most.
No. 01
No tax forecast
Deferring only pays if your tax rate in the payout years is lower than it is today. That means forecasting every income stream you'll have then: RMDs, a business sale, Roth conversions, a move to another state. Without a forecast, you could be blindly locking up more money, and paying more taxes.
No. 02
The wrong payout trigger
One checkbox elected separation. A package arrives, RSUs vest and the bonus pays, then $500K of deferred comp lands on a tax return that already has seven figures of income. In an acquisition, a buyer can terminate the plan and turn a ten-year installment schedule into one check.
No. 03
Going back to work
Plenty of executives retire and get bored fast. Take a new role during your payout years and the W-2 stacks right on top. A re-deferral elected 12+ months ahead can push those payments out five years, caught in time.
No. 04
Investments on default
The first deferral often lands in a target-date fund keyed to age 65, even when the money pays at separation. Some plans invest the whole account as one, so money paying out two years later, and money paying in ten get the same mix. While parking it in cash loses ground to inflation every year.
No. 05
Ignoring who owes you
These plans aren't protected like a 401(k). The balance is an unsecured promise from your employer, and in a bankruptcy you stand in line with other creditors. More than 300 Lehman Brothers executives received nothing.
The nuance most people miss
The details that separate a plan from a guess.
Nobody brags about a deferral election at a cocktail party. It's unsexy tax savings. That's why it gets glossed over.
Payroll tax is paid once, early
Social Security and Medicare tax hits deferred comp when it vests, not when it pays. In a vesting year you've usually already passed the Social Security wage base ($184,500 in 2026), so that part rounds to zero. After that, the payouts and all the growth come out payroll-tax free.
A rabbi trust protects you from a change of heart, not a bankruptcy
It guards against a new CFO or a new owner who would rather not pay. It sits inside the company's walls, so if the company fails, that money is in line with everyone else the company owes.
Is it crowding out another tax strategy?
Deferral income paid in your 60s can eat the low-income years you were counting on for Roth conversions or targeted 0% capital gain rates for the years you'd use to reduce a concentrated stock position.
It changes your whole portfolio
If the plan holds less risk, you may be able to take more outside it. Anding a brokerage account gives you liquidity and tax-loss harvesting that deferred money never will.
How much to defer
Four tests before you pick a percentage.
Participants average 10% of salary and 23% of bonus (PSCA 2025). Your right number comes out of the forecast, not the average.
No. 01
Rate
What's your marginal rate today, and what's it forecast to be in each payout year? This is the whole game.
No. 02
Cash
Can your household lock up this cash flow? Deferral comes from surplus, never from the money you might need.
No. 03
Credit
Your employer already pays your salary. Add company stock and deferred comp, and it's three layers of exposure to one company. We cap the total.
No. 04
Coordination
Get the 401(k) match first, always. After that, the order depends on the forecast and the other tax saving strategies you're counting on.
The deferred comp checklist
Five questions to answer before the deadline.
If you can answer all five, you're ahead of most people in your plan. If you can't, get the full checklist. It's free, and you don't need to hire us to use it.
Get the checklist
01
What is my projected tax rate in each payout year, not just this one?
02
What are my plan's payout triggers, and did I choose the form or default into it?
03
What is my total exposure to my employer (paycheck, stock, options and deferred comp) as one number?
04
How is the money in the plan invested, and does my financial plan assume the same thing?
05
If I left next year, by choice or not, what would I forfeit and what would pay out early?
FAQ
Deferred comp questions, answered plainly.
What is a 409A deferred compensation plan?
A nonqualified plan that lets corporate executives postpone part of their salary or bonus, and the income tax on it, to a later year. The payout form and triggers are set by the plan and your election.
How much of my pay should I defer?
It depends on your tax rate today versus in each payout year, your cash needs, how much of your wealth already depends on your employer, and your other plans. Start with the forecast, not a percentage.
Can I change my deferred comp election?
Usually not once the year starts. For a 409A plan, the main exception is a re-deferral: elected at least 12 months before the payment date and pushing payment out at least five years.
Is deferred compensation safe?
It's an unsecured promise from your employer. A rabbi trust protects against a change of heart, not a bankruptcy. Your employer's financial strength belongs in the decision.
What happens to my deferred comp if I leave or my company is acquired?
Most plans pay at separation, and many pay at a change in control. A buyer can also terminate the plan and pay everything out within a set window, possibly in a single high-income year.
Can I roll a 457(b) into an IRA?
A governmental 457(b), yes. A non-governmental 457(b), from a hospital, university or other nonprofit, cannot be rolled to an IRA.
Do I pay Social Security and Medicare tax on deferred comp?
Yes, but usually once, and early. Payroll tax applies when the money vests, not when it pays out. If you've already passed the Social Security wage base that year ($184,500 in 2026), that part rounds to zero. After that, the payouts and all the growth come out free of payroll tax.
Can you just help with my deferred comp?
Our work is built around ongoing coordination, not one-time projects. A standalone review gives you an answer without the context of your full picture, and the costly mistakes happen where those pieces meet. If your current advisor can close the gap with the right questions, we'll tell you what to ask them.
Have us review your election before you sign.
Bring your enrollment packet and plan document. In 30 minutes you'll know the two or three things we'd look at first, whether or not we work together.